Keith Ferrazzi, author of the book Never Eat Alone, and his team compared the method of change management and addiction treatment (3). Keith made an analogy between the AA method and the change management method in his article. AA uses a 12-step program and has a superior track record. Here are my experiences with the analogy in the article.
1- Nothing happens without readiness to change.
As discussed previously in model 2, people will not change if they are not ready. We can’t force people to change. We can only help them want to change.
People are ready to change when they hit a crisis or rock bottom. Sometimes an admission of vulnerability is a sign of readiness. I was once engaged because the organisation wanted to break their current practices.
When people come to you for help, it is a sign that they are ready to make new connections (and prepared to change). So, be on the lookout for readiness. Use model 1 to guide people through this stage.
2- It’s important to replace old habits with new ones.
In AA meetings, coffee is served instead of alcohol. In change management, the goal is to replace negative habits with positive ones.
In one project, we replaced an exit with another. Previously, ingredients and wastes were entering the manufacturing area using the same door; The issue with this flow is cross-contamination and congestion. To solve this, we created an additional door for waste. We have replaced one exit for the wastes with another by doing so. The outcome was better process flow, preventing contamination and improved safety.
3- Peer support and pressure drive change.
AA methods gather people with similar problems together. As in model 2, find your supporters and grow your supporters. Keep your supporters close and meet often.
Change management tends to drop off the radar after the initial push. It is important to keep meeting and keep challenging each other.
4- Sponsorship deepens commitment and sparks results.
AA pairs experienced members with newcomers for one-on-one support. In change management, this refers to peer coaching or mentorship.
When I started to implement lean, I had a more experienced colleague than me in the early years. We met frequently and challenged each other’s ideas. There were good ideas from each of us, and mostly, we found admiration and respect between us. He helped me see lean as a solution and not a set of tools. This means always starting your lean journey with a problem already at hand. Do not start with a tool (such as 5S) and then hunt for the problem.
5- A community without hierarchy is a catalyst for change.
AA is famous for self-directed groups. It is not too different in change management. One of my most prominent lean achievements was a direct result of a self-directed group. As the head of a department, I have moved my QC team to the warehouse and redesigned the layout to facilitate a testing program. At the early implementation stage, we did not get the results as expected. After a few months, when the QC-Warehouse team began to understand the concept, they worked together and found a way that worked. There was over 100% improvement. The important thing was there was no leader in the group. They just came together and worked it out themselves.
6- You are the company you keep.
AA discourages members from associating with their old drinking buddies. In the change management aspect, the analogy is to have sceptics among believers of change. However, there are usually more sceptics than believers at the start of the change journey.
One way is to grow your group of supporters. In my earlier example (point 9 of model 2), where I increased the believers to 50% after four years, it started with my department and direct reports. With results coming in overtime, we gained more and more supporters. We keep each other accountable via Gemba walks (point 8 of model 2). We displayed results to remind ourselves and others of our successes, which gave us the confidence to try new things.
7- Continuous introspection is key.
In AA, members examine their past behaviour and start trying to change. I would compare this to a regular review. Once you put a change in place, find a way to monitor it. However, be careful in using metrics. It can be counterproductive. I found it beneficial to use existing metrics and analyse them to show the results instead of creating new ones.
8 – It pays to acknowledge small wins.
AA doesn’t ask members never to drink again but not drink that day. According to Kotter (3), corporate transformation falls short because managers fail to “systematically plan for short term wins”. The keyword is “systematically plan”. This means some form of consistency in pushing the change initiatives. Keep looking for small changes. Make sure there are regular reporting on small wins.
Small wins create new connections in people’s brains, which we are after.
9- The goal is progress, not perfection.
Ninety percent of recovering alcoholics relapse at some point. Perhaps this number is also valid with change initiatives because it requires a new connection in the brain for people to accept change. Creating new connections is not impossible, but it takes time and persistence.
The most effective way to create a new connection is by focusing on short term and consistent learning. “Based on his work with plasticity, Edward Taub has discovered “….. training should be done in increments, and work should be concentrated into a short time, a training technique Taub calls “massed practice,” which he has found far more effective than long-term but less frequent training. (1).”
This research on brain plasticity affirms that the goal is progress and not perfection.
_________________________________________
Summary
We have covered three change models. They are different in many ways; however, the core message is to change the mindset by creating new connections. A successful change program is likely to combine all these three models.
The success rate depends on the change agent picking the right model and using it skillfully.
___________________________________________
References
(1) The Brain That Changes Itself by Norman Doidge, MD; pp 156; Penguin Books.
(2) Quiet Leadership by David Rock; Harpers Collins.
(3) Managing Change, one day at a Time by Kieth Ferrazzi; Harvard Business Review, August 2014.
Three successful change models (Part 1) – Rewire the brain
Three successful change models (Part 2) – Methods from reality TV